Who really has the best breakfast sandwich?

By: Olive Varvel

Forget avocado toast and complicated quinoa. The true king of the morning meal wears a crown of flaky, golden-brown buttermilk pastry. The sausage, egg, and cheese biscuit is a masterclass in textual contrast and indulgence. By combining the sharp snap of melted cheddar with rich, spiced pork and soft-folded eggs, this breakfast sandwich proves that sometimes the best way to start the day doesn’t have to be fancy.

Camilla Bozzuto, Ella Kapfhammer, and Alaina Bayer took on the challenge of judging breakfast sandwiches.

Alaina Bayer, Camilla Bozzuto, Ella Kapfhammer, and I put four breakfast sandwiches to the test to find out which one really deserves a spot in your morning routine.

McDonald’s – 5/10

McDonald’s was our baseline, delivering the familiar breakfast sandwich we all know. I found it enjoyable, largely because I eat McDonald’s breakfast sandwiches fairly often, but I did think it was a bit dry and salty and Bayer also found the biscuit dry.

“The biscuit is surprisingly super good. It has a salty flavor that I like,” Bozzuto said.

Kapfhammer was pleasantly surprised, saying it was better than she expected. The sandwich had a classic breakfast flavor, but the crumbly and dryness of the biscuit were some drawbacks. During our discussion, we noted how easily the McDonald’s biscuit fell apart, which made it a little less enjoyable to eat.

Chick-fil-A – 8/10

Chick-fil-A quickly became a strong contender. I found the sandwich more flavorful than McDonald’s, with the seared sausage looking especially appetizing, while Bozzuto thought the biscuit was sweeter.

“I like the egg and cheese, it was fluffier and better overall,” Kapfhammer said.

The biscuit was the standout. Tasters described it as buttery, slightly sweet, and reminiscent of a homemade biscuit. Ms. Bills-Tenney even noted the subtle honey-like flavor complemented the sausage and cheese. While the sandwich was a little messy and soft, the flavor combination made up for it.

Warehouse 4 – 6/10

Warehouse 4 brought a more unique experience, particularly with its biscuit and sauce. It looked like a perfect square shape, suggesting that they cook large amounts of biscuit and egg at one time and cut them into squares. I personally enjoyed the sauce because it seemed tangy and rich.

Unfortunately, the gravy sauce wasn’t a hit with everyone. Bozzuto and Bayer found it cold and unappealing, and Kapfhammer didn’t enjoy it as much as Chick-fil-A. Although the biscuit had potential, the overall experience was a little less consistent.

Socialite Cafe – 7/10

Socialite Cafe offered a different take on the breakfast sandwich, swapping the biscuit for an English muffin. Although it wasn’t part of the biscuit competition, it still made a strong impression on the group.

I enjoyed the gouda cheese, and it was definitely my favorite of the four sandwiches. The sandwich was less egg-heavy, which appealed to those who weren’t big fans of eggs.

“I noticed the Socialite Cafe sandwich has more egg white and less yolk, which made it less overpowering,” Bayer said.

Several tasters compared the flavor to Starbucks, giving it a familiar, comforting feel. The Socialite Cafe also included a hashbrown for us to taste, which earned some praise. It included rosemary seasoning, which added a distinct flavor.

The Final Verdict

Best Biscuit: Chick-fil-A — Its sweeter, buttery flavor was the standout
Best Overall Flavor: Socialite Cafe — The cheese, balanced flavor, and Starbucks feel made it a favorite
Most Unique: Warehouse 4 — Its homemade biscuit and tangy gravy flavor definitely made this biscuit have an interesting flavor.
Best Value: McDonalds — The McDonalds app provides cheap deals, allowing anyone who signs up for a free account to save over $3 on a breakfast sandwich every day. This is a great, cheap option for those who are looking for an everyday breakfast sandwich.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.